| YEAR | UMPIRE | CHAPTER |
|---|---|---|
| 1991 | FRANK PENALE | NIAGARA FALLS |
| 1992 | DICK ARCURI | UTICA |
| 1993 | BILL O'BRIEN | ROCKLAND COUNTY |
| 1994 | JOE KIBLER | LOCKPORT |
| 1995 | NASH PAGANO | GLENS FALLS |
| 1996 | MIKE NORTHUP | HORNELL |
| 1997 | ANTHONY "CHIEF" CATANIA | JAMESTOWN |
| 1998 | STEVE PAVLOVICH | ENDICOTT |
| 1999 | HERM CARD | SYRACUSE |
| 2000 | JAMES ANDERSEN, Sr. | SCHENECTADY |
| 2000 | RON GABRIEL | COLUMBIA-GREENE |
| 2001 | JOE GRADY | WESTERN SUFFOLK |
| 2002 | JOE MILLER | ALLEGANY/GENESEE VALLEY |
| 2003 | BOB SITTERLEY | MOHAWK VALLEY |
| 2004 | ROBERT LANG | WESTERN SUFFOLK |
| 2005 | RON GOOD | ALLEGANY |
| 2006 | DON MOLINO | SCHENECTADY/CAPITAL DISTRICT |
| 2007 | TOM PETROFF | SYRACUSE |
| 2008 | RICK AHLFELD | MASSENA |
| 2009 | IRA LEVINE | WESTERN SUFFOLK |
| 2010 | JOHN CATALINE | GENEVA |
| 2011 | JERRY DAVITT | SULLIVAN |
| 2012 | JIM GUISE | WESTERN SUFFOLK |
| 2013 | ROBERT VAN ALSTYNE | SCHENECTADY |
| 2014 | SI KAUFMAN | MID HUDSON |
| 2015 | WARREN BUMPUS | SYRACUSE |
| 2016 | DICK LINDEMEYER | ALLEGANY |
| 2017 | DON VOLK | CATTARAUGUS |
| 2018 | MARK ROTHROCK | GENESEE VALLEY |
| 2019 | FR. JERRY BARTKO | LOCKPORT |
| 2021 | MIKE GALLO | WATERTOWN |
| 2022 | JERRY REILLY | CHAUTAUQUA |